SYMBOLIC OVERTONE IN ROBERT FROST’S POETRY || Thesis paper || Research paper
Robert Frost was a very famous poet. He left an imprint in this world by creating mind blowing poems that let readers experience deep emotions through words.
Robert Frost usually
focuses his poems on a person’s everyday experiences, but he also adds many
metaphors that relate to his everyday experiences, weather, seasons and nature
in general. In many of Frost’s poems he expresses his emotions by using
symbolism.
Symbols
are words that stand for or denote something else, not by exact resemblance,
but by vague suggestion. So, symbolic poetry is evocative rather than
descriptive. Symbolism
is the practice of representing things by symbols. A symbolic poet does not
convey his
meaning by direct statement; he uses words with symbolic meaning to convey his ideas. Even the symbolic poems have surface meanings but rich symbols add deeper meanings to
words. Again, Symbols are essentially words which are not merely
connotative, but also evocative and emotive. In addition to their meaning, they
also call up or evoke before the mind's eye a host of associations connected
with them, and are also rich in emotional significance. For example, the word
'lily' merely connotes a 'flower' but it also evokes images of beauty and
innocence. It also carries with it the emotional overtone of pity resulting
from suffering or oppression. In this way, through symbols a writer can
express much more than by the use of ordinary words; symbols make the language
rich and expressive. Concepts which by their very nature are inexpressible can
be conveyed in this way. Thus a symbol can be used to convey, "Pure
sensations", or the poet's apprehension of transcendental, mystery.
Many of Robert Frost's poems are simple and plain, but
there are poems
that are rich in symbolic content and have symbolic overtones. Frost wanted to be known as a symbolic poet as is
evident from his following statement:
"I
am, by intention, a symbolic who takes his symbols
from the public domain."
Frost enriches his poems through symbols
which add deeper meaning to particular situations, events and happenings.
W.B. Yeats was a truly symbolist poet who drew his inspiration
from the French symbolists. But Robert Frost is not a symbolic poet of the order of Yeats. Still he is
in the line of Yeats and hence a truly modern poet, although many
critics deny him the title of a
modern poet and dub him as a conventional poet.
Robert Frost was a regional poet who drew
his inspiration and material
from New England region of America—to be exact, the area which lies north of
Boston. The people of his poetry are the people of New England, their
language the language of New England people. His
themes also have a bearing on New England situation, its people, its weather, its hardships, and its beliefs. Frost
celebrated New England in poem after poem. The New England region
becomes a microcosm of the world at large,
and the Yankee characters become symbols
of human nature everywhere and in all ages.
Take for example the poem "Mending Wall." The surface meaning of the poem is well expressed by the line:
"Good fences make good neighbors." ("Mending
Wall"; L-45)
But the poem becomes more significant when taken on a symbolic
level. Speaking about the symbolism of this poem Lynen observes, : "The
poem seems merely descriptive and anecdotal in character, yet everyone who has
read it will remember a certain feeling of puzzlement, a sense that Frost is
driving at some point which one is not quite able to grasp. We are told how the
speaker in the poem and his neighbor get together every spring to repair the
stone wall between their properties.
The neighbor, a. crusty New England farmer, seems to have a deep-seated
faith in the value of walls. He declines
to explain his belief and will only reiterate his father's saying, ‘Good fences
make good neighbors.' The speaker is of the opposite opinion.
As he points out:
There where it is we do not need the wall;
He is all pine and I am apple orchard. ("Mending Wall"; L-23, 24)
To him the neighbor’s adherence to his father's saying suggests
the narrowness and blind habit of the primitive:
He moves in darkness as it seems. To me,
‘Not of woods only and the shade of trees. ("Mending Wall"; L-
41, 42)
Yet the speaker's own attitude is also enigmatic and in some
respects primitive. He seems to be in sympathy with some elemental spirit in
nature which denies all boundaries:
Sometime there is that doesn't love a wall
That sends the frozen ground-swell under it
And spills the upper boulders in the sun;
And makes gaps even two can pass
abreast......
No one has seen them made or heard them
made,
But at spring mending-time we find them
there......
Something there is that doesn't love a
wall,
That wants it down. I could say 'Elves' to him,
But it's not elves exactly, and I'd rather
He said it for himself. (“Mending Wall”)
The poem
portrays a clash between these two points of view, and it may therefore seem
that its meaning is the solution Frost offers to the disagreement. The poem
leads one to ask, which is right, the speaker or his Yankee neighbor? Should
man tear down the barriers which isolate individuals from one another, or
should he recognize that distinctions and limits are necessary to human life?
Frost does not really provide an answer, and the attempt to wrest one from his
casual details and enigmatic comments would falsify his meaning. It is not
Frost's purpose to convey a message or give us a pat lesson in human relations.
Though the poem presents the speaker's attitude more sympathetically than the
neighbor’s, it does not offer this as the total meaning. Frost's intent is to
portray a problem and explore the many different and paradoxical issues it
involves. He pictures it within the incidents from rural life, and in order to
reveal its complex nature he develops it through the conflict of two opposed
points of view. The clash between the speaker and his neighbor lays bare the
issue, which within their world is the simple matter of whether or not it is
worthwhile to maintain the unnecessary wall in defiance of nature's persistent
attempt to tear it down. But one cannot avoid looking at this problem in other
contexts of experience. The wall becomes the symbol of all kinds of man-made
barriers. The two views of it represent general attitudes towards life—the one,
a surrender to the natural forces which draw human beings together, the other,
the conservatism which persists in keeping up distinctions separating them.
Thus the poem represents the clash between the spirit of revolt and the spirit
of restraint. The first challenges tradition, while the latter adheres to the
tradition.
From the
above it becomes apparent that the poem "Mending Wall" yields an
interpretation which is wider and deeper in scope than its surface meaning. On
a superficial level one can find only one meaning but on a deeper reading the
poem unfolds new vistas of meaning till now unthought-of. The wall is the
shining star of this poem. It unites our speaker and his neighbor, but separates
them as well. As we hear the neighbors speak the proverb twice. We start to
consider all of the wall-like structures in our life: fences, gates,
boundaries, lines, etc. The wall serves as a canvas upon which a lot of complex
ideas about the ways in which people, and their relationships with others, are
painted and discussed.
Again,
Nature seems to act as the third wheel in this poem – the silent character
swirling around the speaker and his neighbor. Although he doesn’t explicitly
describe the landscape, we see it very clearly, and we seem to know what the
seasons are like in this part of the world. Similarly, tradition seems to be
the silent subject over which the speaker and his neighbor wrestle. The
neighbor upholds his ancestors’ way of life, while our speaker questions this
philosophy.
The poem “Fire and Ice” is another symbolic poem of Robert Frost.
This short epigrammatic poem was first published by Frost in the December 1920
issue of Harper’s Magazine. It was later collected by him in New Hampshire, a
collection of his verse. In the poem the poet speculates about the end of the
world. Some say that the world will end in fire, other maintain that it will
come to and end in ice. The poem describes a fictional debate between people
who say that the world will end in fire and people who say it will end in ice.
It is a highly symbolic debate.
The poet
says-
Some say the world will
end in fire,
Some say in ice. (“Fire and Ice”; L, 1-2)
Lines 1 and 2: These two lines have a parallel structure,
beginning with "Some say." This phrase is an example of alliteration. Fire and ice, as we
mentioned above, are symbols. Specifically, they represent emotions like
"desire" and "hate." But be careful – there's no reason to
think that these are all that fire and ice represent. Desire and hate
are merely examples that fall in a broader category.
The poem
revolves around the two symbols of fire and ice. In the first two lines, we
don't yet know that they are symbols. Judging by these lines alone, this could
be a poem about theories of modern science. But when the speaker associates
fire with desire and ice with hate, we know that fire and ice are symbols for
human behaviors and emotions. But the poem does not close down possibilities
for your imagination to run wild by telling us exactly what these two basic
forces represent. You should feel free to relate them to your own thoughts and
experiences and come up with an interpretation.
The poem
itself does not require a large amount of explanation as to meaning of words or
phrases, due to Frost’s concentration on making the poem readable and
understandable by all. Despite the simplicity of the language use, the poem
carries with it very deep thematic ideas. Essentially, Frost is providing
commentary upon two of the darkest traits of humanity: the capacity to hate,
and the capacity to be consumed by lust. Of the two, he attributes the greater
of two evils to desire, saying
“From
what I’ve tasted of desire
I hold with those who favor
fire.” (“Fire
and Ice”; L, 3-4)
In
giving desire the foremost position in regards to the destruction of the world,
Frost is providing a powerful statement on the subject of greed and jealousy,
saying that above all else, even hatred, this is the trait of humanity that is
most likely to lead to its demise. To Frost, desire represents the greatest
problem that the world faces. In light of the fact that this was written in
regards to the Great War, this statement is essentially attributing the cause
of the war to human greed and lust, in doing so providing a current and
relatable warning against this behavior in the future. Following his statement
upon fire and desire, Frost then attributes hatred with almost the same
capacity to do harm as desire, saying
“I think I know enough of hate
to say
that for destruction ice…would suffice.”
Is also
great
And would suffice. (“Fire and Ice”; L, 6-9)
And would suffice. (“Fire and Ice”; L, 6-9)
While this lessens the relative importance of
hatred in regards to the poem as a whole, it is still presented as having the
ability to lead to the destruction of the world if it were to happen for a
second time, again providing a powerful warning against this human fallacy.
Overall, then, the intention and meaning behind the poem is a basic desire on
Frost’s part to warn, in his own manner, against what he sees as the two
greatest problems facing humanity.
Symbolism
is the key to this poem. Frost very explicitly makes fire a symbol for desire,
and ice a symbol for hate. This, coupled with the imagery that these symbols
evoke, creates a multidimensional complexity to the poem. Because of the deeper
meaning that fire and ice take on, the application and understanding of the
poem is altered. While the poem still is interpreted as a warning against these
behaviors in the broad scheme of the world, in concordance with the war that
was occurring, it also begins to take on a more personal level. Namely, this is
due to the personal connection that is shared by the creation of these symbols,
with fire and desire, ice and hate. The poem is then applied to one’s everyday
life, and is interpreted as a warning against vices of desire and hatred in day
to day life, not just in the larger world. Therefore, by making fire and ice a
symbol, and forcing the reader to consider their application to the poem and
it’s broader warning, this warning is then applied to the reader’s own life,
increasing the effectiveness and impact of the poem.
"Fire
and Ice" bears many of the characteristics that represent the body of work
for Robert Frost. It is written in a simple manner, using a language set and
vernacular that is designed to be easily understood. As is also a trend with
Frost in his poetry, the subject matter of the poem deals deeply with human
nature, exploring the implicit human emotions of desire and hatred. This
subject matter, too, has a large capacity to be relatable to the audience, as
it shares in collective human experience, in feelings that are experienced by
all. Also in concurrence to the habits of Frost, these darker, deeper themes
are presented in contrast to the simplicity and openness of the actual language
of the poem, done intentionally to highlight the underlying theme. As a poem,
this work also represents a significant break from the larger body of work of
Robert Frost. While many of his poems are regionalist in nature, dealing with
common aspects of life of New England, this poem does not exhibit the heavily regionalist
nature, instead exhibiting a complete lack of it. This too is done to provide a
point of contrast. By placing this poem outside of the ‘norm” for himself,
Frost is able to effectively draw attention to this poem, lending a deeper
level of significance to the poem and its warning. The regionalism of Frost's
work, as well as the break from it that is represented by "Fire and
Ice" can be seen in two of Frost's most famous poems “The Road Not Taken”
and “Stopping by the Woods on a Snowy Evening”
As it can
be seen, these works have a heavy focus upon the New England setting, a trait
that, as aforementioned is not seen in "Fire and Ice." These two
poems do share elements with "Fire and Ice," namely in the pattern of
presenting deep, important themes under the guise of simple, understated words.
This creates this previously mentioned accessibility to all audiences, while
giving the poetry significant literary merit.
Robert
Frost poems are singular for their deceptive simplicity. The poem "The
Road Not Taken" is also rich in symbolic meaning. It also is a pretty poem
about nature, but with much deeper symbolic meaning. On the surface level the poem is about a man
who finds himself on a crossing and cannot decide which road to take. Ultimately
he decides to move on the road that was less frequented. On the symbolic level
the poem can represent the predicament of the poet when faced with two lines of
poetic development. The poet, like the man, finally, must choose the less
frequented road only because in this his chance to fame lies. The choice is all
important for the poet and he says, it made all the difference. The destination
of the poet is determined by the spirit behind the man.
“The Road Not Taken” One of
his most well known poems, it strikes a chord with any who read it. The
symbolism featured within has been the subject of a wide variety of
interpretations; however, most insist that this poem symbolizes the incessant
curiosity that resides within human nature. Whichever choice is taken in life,
one will always wonder what possibilities the other choice may have held.
Many interpretations have been
made of this poem, but Frost himself claimed the inspiration came from his dear
friend Edward Thomas, a welsh poet whom he’d met in England. It was said that
Thomas was never content with the choices he made, and whenever walking with
Frost in England, would always regret path they had chosen. Frost had even said
to Thomas, “No matter which road you take, you’ll always sigh, and wish you’d
taken another”. The poem is a gentle teasing of not only his friend’s constant
regret and curiosity, but also that of human behavior. The subtle humor found
at the end of Frost’s poem gently pokes fun of humanity’s unsatisfied and
curious nature on one level, but also sheds light upon the finalities of
choice, and the lost opportunities that go with them.
Within the four stanzas of
“The Road Not Taken” the speaker narrates coming across two roads while walking
through the woods one autumn morning. The symbolic value of the forking roads
is fairly easy to grasp, representing the choices that one comes across
throughout the journey of life. Regretful that he can choose only one, the
speaker is careful in his choice of road,
“And be
one traveler, long I stood
And
looked down one as far as I could
To where
it bent in the undergrowth;” (“The Road Not Taken” lines 3-5).
This is where much of the debate on theme and
symbolism begins. For instance, an article written by William Pritchard, claims
that the speaker’s choice between the roads was a matter of impulse, and not
one of careful decision, because of the emphasis he put on the similarities
between the roads .
Three times within the first
three stanzas, the speaker mentions how the roads are virtually the same. First
by describing the roads
“Then took the other as just as fair” (“The Road Not Taken”; line
6),
Then with
“Though as for that the passing there
Had worn them really about the same” (“The Road Not Taken”; lines
9-10),
And finishing with lines
eleven and twelve, saying
“And
both that morning equally lay
In leaves no step had trodden
black.”(“The
Road Not Taken”; lines 11-12)
Many claim that he contradicts himself here,
and attempts to deceive himself as well as his audience by claiming the path he
took was “grassy and wanted wear” the poet says:
Because it
was grassy and wanted wear; (“The Road Not Taken” line -8).
That instead, there was no
road less traveled by, and in saying so the speaker is really just attempting
to glorify his impulsive choice.
However, it may be more
appropriate to see the speaker in a different light. He is not lying about the
roads, but rather, he studies them long enough until he can find any difference
between them. After all, he is faced with a choice, and cannot continue until
he chooses, so it is not unreasonable to think that he would take as much
consideration as possible in making his decision.
When evaluating the symbolism
side by side with the theme here, one can see that instead of just being roads
passing through a wood, they are instead roads that lead down different paths
in life. And so the caution exhibited by the speaker would be expected. Though
initially the paths seem to be the same, upon closer inspection one can see the
differences that would result in different outcomes in life. The speaker does
admit in line seven that the road holds only
“And having perhaps the
better claim,” (“The
Road Not Taken”; line- 7)
Because the differences
between them are so few, it is difficult for the speaker to be completely sure
in his decision.
The roads symbolism is seen
throughout the theme of the entire poem, and sheds light upon the nature of
human thought and indecision. The poem is an example of the “difficult but
necessary process of making choices in life” the poet says
Then took the other, as just as fair, (“The Road Not Taken”;line
6)
It is difficult to make a choice that will
affect the outcome of one’s life, and human nature lends to curiosity. What
could have been? What opportunities were gained, and what opportunities were
lost by the choice made?
Unsatisfied with the unknown,
the speaker tries to convince himself that he will have the opportunity to
someday return and experience the other path. Life, however, does not work this
way, and the speaker knows this.
“Yet knowing how way leads on to way,
I doubted if I should ever come back” (“The Road Not Taken”; lines
14-15).
Even if the reader were able to return and
travel the other road, the circumstances would never again be the same they
were at that moment, on that particular day. As Jennifer Bouchard says in her
article, “Because one cannot go down two roads at once, there is no way to be
certain where different choices would have led”
The last stanza in Frost’s
“The Road Not Taken” is perhaps the most important regarding the theme and
symbolism found within the poem. When studying the lines below, one can see how
many different interpretations have been made regarding the entire poem from
this last stanza.
“I shall be telling this with a sigh
Somewhere ages and ages hence:
Two Roads diverged in a wood, and I--
I took the one less traveled by,
And that has made all the difference.”(“The Road Not Taken”; Lines
16-20)
In line sixteen, the first
line of the last stanza, Frost’s choice of the word “sigh” leads some to
believe that his future become of the road he ultimately took, is a grim one.
That he is regretful because his outcome in life is unhappy, and it can be
traced back to that day in the woods. An interpretive article written by Terry
Andrews implies the choice “has made all the difference” allowing that the
“difference” was for the worse.
However, rather than regarding
the “sigh” as a purely negative word, it could just as easily been seen as a
sigh of relief, or perhaps a sigh of resignation, with each choice one makes,
the circumstances of the other is lost, and therefore it is impossible to know
what could have been . It seems to be the speaker’s “sigh” resonates with the
latter. His human curiosity burns within him, regardless of which choice was
made, he would still want to know what possibilities in life he passed by.
The fact that one choice made
between two roads which initially seemed so equal, can actually make “all the
difference,” symbolizes the power of possibilities and circumstance in life.
“Way,” does indeed “lead on to way,” and there is no turning back. A path in
life that seems to be the same as another contains subtle differences that lead
to different outcomes. It is the nature of humanity, with its innate curiosity,
and regretful demeanor that makes it difficult for a person to be completely
content with the road he chooses to take in life. Regardless of the
opportunities he gained along his way, the simple fact that he will never know
what could have been, that he will never know what he may have missed in his
journey of life, will leave him always wondering of “The Road Not Taken.”
Robert frost is known as
the Nature poet, modern poet, and a Lyric poet. We find natural element in his
poetry He is also known as Regional poet. John F. Lynen Says that Frost has so
man and such excellent poems about natural scenery and wild life, “that one can
hardly avoid thinking of him as a natural poet”. We can find some element
of Modernity like his Pastoral Technique, Attitude towards Nature-Realism and
Metaphysical technique. We find symbolism in his poetry like natural symbol in
the poem "Stopping by Woods on a Snowy Evening".
The poem
"Stopping by Woods on a Snowy Evening" is also rich in symbolic
overtones. The theme of the poem is simple enough: it is the description of .a
scene of the woods and the circumstances under which the narrator has stopped
there. But behind this seeming simplicity there runs a meaning which is
far-reaching in its effects. Although this moving personal experience has been
exquisitely rendered, yet in reconsidering it one cannot quite shake off the
feeling that something more is intended that is apparent on the superficial
level. Lynen says, "The poem is not just a record of something that once
happened to the poet; it points outward from the moment described toward far
broader areas of experience. It expresses the conflict which everyone has felt,
between the demands of practical life, with its obligations to others, and the
poignant desire to escape into a land of reverie, where consciousness is dimmed
and the senses are made independent of necessity."The woods which the poet
admires so perfectly are opposed to the promises that the poet has to keep.”
Further, the poet tells us about his intention of sleeping only when he has
kept his promises, when sleep becomes a reward of a well-earned toil. It was
this symbolism of the poem which so attracted our beloved Prime Minister,
Jawaharlal Nehru, that he kept the last lines of the poem on his work table:
The woods are lovely, dark, and deep,
But I have promises to keep,
But I have promises to keep,
And miles to go before I sleep,
And miles to go before I sleep. ("Stopping by Woods on a Snowy Evening”; L, 13-16)
And miles to go before I sleep. ("Stopping by Woods on a Snowy Evening”; L, 13-16)
This poem is one of the
most quietly moving of frost’s lyrics. The lyric is Simplicity itself. Poem
starts with the question like,
“Whose
woods these are I think I know”. ("Stopping by Woods on a Snowy
Evening”; L-1)
Here we find that our
speaker is sound confuse, he is not confident about the owner of the woods. The
speaker thinks that he knows the owner of the woods, and he lives in a house in
the village and village is not the most hopping’ place in the world. And he
feels calm because he knows that the owner of the wood is not present in the
wood so he can move freely in it. Here snow is a kind of Temptation. The poem
is about the continuity of time and life. Poet is talking about the idea of
spiritual
“He will not see me
stopping here
To watch his woods fill up with snow”("Stopping
by Woods on a Snowy Evening";L-3,4)
Here God is symbolizing
as village and woods. The illusion of poet we can see here because as we know
that good is everywhere though poet believes that the owner of the wood can’t
see him. Here woods are symbolized as nature and the owner of the nature is
god. “My little horse” is use for “the soul” and horse is a kind of a tool to
rich your destination. There is something strange for the horse because our
speaker stop his horse in the woods and near the farm house so horse could not
find the reason of speaker’s stop at middle. Poet stops in between woods and a
lake which is frozen with snow, because he was fascinated by the beauty of the
woods and frozen lake. And between the woods and frozen lake symbolize the
period of birth to death.
“The darkest evening of the year”.("Stopping
by Woods on a Snowy Evening",L-8)
The darkest evening of
the year mean by him is about the season of winter. And winter symbolizes the
death. And the other meaning of it is that the one fourth parts of a day and a
day means a life. Poet is saying that “Life is like a day” and the darkest
evening is the worst time of the soul or may be for poet or an individuals. The
darkest evening of the year is also symbolized as near to die or about to
die.
“He gives his harness bells a shake”. ("Stopping
by Woods on a Snowy Evening"; L-9)
Bell is a kind of guide
here. And here the line suggests that a person who can predict the bad or worst
situation before the things will happen by getting some signs. So here bell is
use as symbol for make him aware about the place. And instead of bells ringing
sound we find the sound of sweeping, and this comes from the slight wind and
softly falling snow.
And the last four line of
the last stanza has a very deep meaning.
“The woods are lovely, dark and deep.”("Stopping
by Woods on a Snowy Evening"; L-13)
Poet connects the word
woods with life and the meaning of this line is that life is lovely as well as
dark, it means full of risk and difficulty. And deep it means whatever happens
with us throughout our life that is difficult to understand some times. So the
complexity of life is symbolized with the word deep.
“But I have promises to keep”("Stopping by Woods on a Snowy
Evening";L-14)
The line suggests
that whatever the life of an individual he or she has to live. Everyone has to
accept the truth or reality of their life and try to live with it. And the last
two lines are very important.
“And miles to go before I sleep.
And miles to go before I sleep.”("Stopping by Woods on a Snowy
Evening"; L-15,16)
The line suggest that
Death is the ultimate reality of the life but before that an individual has
some duty to fulfill and the words like “and miles to go” suggest the same
thing that there are so many works and responsibility an individual has
and he has to complete before the end of his life. And “before I sleep” it
symbolizes the death.
After the above discursion we find these
symbols in the poem "Stopping
by Woods on a Snowy Evening"
Ø Woods:- Here woods are symbolizes as contrast to
civilization. In line 1, 4, 7 and 13 some interpret the woods as an extended
metaphor for death.
Ø The natural world:- In natural
world the snow is symbol of coolness and the frozen lake is symbol of the
death and chillness of life means unable to help even the self also.
Ø Other symbols:- Here we find some
symbol like Village, horse, sleep etc..
Ø Village:- Village is symbolize here as Society and
Civilization.
Ø Horse:- Horse is symbolize as soul.
Ø Sleep:- Sleep is symbolize as Death.
Robert
Frost writes the poem “Stopping By Woods on a Snowy Evening” in 1st person
point of view has symbolic meanings hidden in it.
Stopping by Woods on a Snowy Evening
|
Yet
another poem which is symbolically important is "Out, Out." Robert
Frost’s “‘Out, Out—’” describes a farm accident that unexpectedly and
irrationally costs a young boy his life. A young man is cutting firewood with a
buzz saw in New England. Near the end of the day, the boy’s sister announces
that it is time for dinner and, out of excitement, the boy accidentally cuts his
hand with the saw. He begs his sister not to allow the doctor to amputate the
hand but inwardly realizes that he has already lost too much blood to survive.
The boy dies while under anesthesia, and everyone goes back to work. The
narrator of the poem sets the scene, seemingly from an outsider’s perspective,
reporting the incident with objectivity and restraint. Yet, as the narrative
advances, underlying emotions and tensions surface as the persona builds to the
poem’s conclusion: the seemingly senseless, abrupt ending of the boy’s life,
followed by his family’s subsequent return to their daily routines.
This is
the whole incident which is described in the poem but the pathos is so intense
that we can say that this is the main theme of the poem. The meaning of the
poem can be read through the key of the following lines:
“So. But the hand was gone already": (“Out,
Out”; L-27)
The
boy's first outcry was a rueful laugh, As he swung toward them holding up the
hand Half in appeal, but half as if to keep The life from spilling. Then the boy saw all — Since he was old
enough to know, big boy Doing a man's work, though a child at heart— He saw all
spoiled.
The poet says :
“The boy’s first outcry was a
rueful laugh.”(Out,Out;L-18)
The
pathos of the death of the boy can be understood only when we think about the
results that may ensue after the hand has been lost— how the boy will have to
become dependent on others, how his chef-respect will be hurt. As Lynen says:
"The story symbolizes a tragic aspect as the human situation: the fact
that man's economic means, for the very reason that they are mechanical in
nature, can destroy him. The death may not always be a physical one, as in the
boy's case, but a destruction of man's essential humanity."
In this
poem, the title is taken from Shakespeare’s “Macbeth” in which Macbeth, hearing
of his wife’s death, soliloquizes:
Out, Out,
brief candle
Life’s
but a walking shadow, a poor player
That
struts and frets his hour upon the stage
And then
is heard no more. it is a tale
Told by
an idiot, full of sound and fury,
Signifying
nothing. ( “Macbeth”)
Macbeth here speaks of the meaninglessness of life, it
senselessness and its purposelessness. In frost’s poem, the violent death of
the youth raises similar questions as the life’s value. the opening lines of
the poem create a contrast between the pastoral quietness of the landscape and
the noise of the saw whose snarling sounds make it seem like a wild animal. The
sawing has proceeded routinely , nothing makes the day unique:
“And
nothing happened: day was all but done.”(“Out ,Out”; L-9)
As this point, the poet breaks in his own voice, remarking
Call it a day, I wish they might have said
To please the boy by giving him the half
hour
That a boy counts so much when saved from
work. (“Out,Out”;L-10,11,12)
Trough these words, the
speaker emphasizes the youthful quality of the boy and, by so doing prepares
the reader for a sense of the tragedy of one dying so young. In this
poem Robert Frost deals tragedy by using symbol.
Robert
Frost has written so many poems. Most of the poems he used symbols. At first I
would like to discuss his first published work “My Butterfly”. This poem
contains eight stanzas varying in length from four to ten lines .Frost in meter
or verse expressing various emotions which are expressed by the use of variety
of techniques including symbols, metaphors, similes and onomatopoeia. The
emphasis on the aesthetics of language and the use of techniques such as
repetition, meter and rhyme are what are commonly used to distinguish Robert
Frost poetry from Robert Frost prose. Poems often make heavy use of imagery,
symbols, and word association to quickly convey emotions. A famous example of
Robert Frost poetry is the poem “My Butterfly”. Poetry written such as the poem
“My Butterfly” is a piece of literature written by the American poet Robert
Frost. Throughout the course of the poem, "My Butterfly" by Robert
Frost, the author uses the theme of death and sorrowfulness; a feeling that is
emitted during the loss of a loved one by using symbols.
Robert Frost's poem "My
Butterfly" draws a parallel between a butterfly the narrator is mourning
the death of and the author himself, focusing on the joyfulness he felt the
summer he first saw the butterfly to the sorrow he feels after the butterfly's
death. Frost's agnostic beliefs present themselves in the text.
"My Butterfly" tells
the sorrow felt by the speaker over the death of a butterfly he had seen the
previous summer. The butterfly which once inspired joy and magic in the speaker
now leaves the speaker to question Fate and God as the forces which rule the
cosmos.
In this poem we find a lot of
symbols. “Butterfly” is a symbolical word. Generally butterfly means freedom
but symbolically it is not free.
In the second stanza the poet
says that-
As the
speaker says in the 8th stanza of the poem,
"I found that wing broken today
For
thou art dead, I said.
And
the strange birds say.
I
found it withered leaves
Under the eaves.",( “My Butterfly”.L,43-47)
The quote illustrates how the speak
acknowledges the death of someone after the "wing is broken".
My
Butterfly
|
North of Boston is frost’s “Book of
people” and there are many abnormal and alienated people in it. One such is the
“Over-wrought” mother in the Home Burial cracking up under a burden grief over
the death of her first- born. It is the shadow of her dead child which brings
her in conflict with her husband and alienates them. It is a dramatic dialogue
in which the action is developed through the dialogue between husband and wife.
The couple is caught in a moment of spiritual crisis, and the expression
of their emotion has all the intensity of the lyric.
The poem describes two tragedies: first, the death of a young
child, and second, the death of a marriage. As such, the title “Home Burial,”
can be read as a tragic double entendre. Although the death of the child is the
catalyst of the couple’s problems, the larger conflict that destroys the
marriage is the couple’s inability to communicate with one another. Both
characters feel grief at the loss of the child, but neither is able to
understand the way that their partner chooses to express their sorrow.
The setting of the poem–a staircase with a door at the bottom and
a window at the top– automatically sets up the relationship between the
characters. The wife stands at the top of the stairs, directly in front of the
window overlooking the graveyard, while the husband stands at the bottom of the
stairs, looking up at her. While the couple shares the tragedy of their child’s
death, they are in conflicting positions in terms of dealing with their grief
With her position closest to the window, the wife is clearly still struggling
with her grief over the loss of her baby. Incapable of moving on at this point
in her life, the wife defines her identity in terms of the loss and would
rather grieve for the rest of her life than grieve as a sort of pretense. The
husband has dealt with his sorrow more successfully, as evidenced by his
position at the bottom of the staircase, close to the door and the outside
world. As a farmer, the husband is more accepting of the natural cycle of life
and death in general, but also chooses to grieve in a more physical manner: by
digging the grave for his child. Ironically, the husband’s expression of his
grief is completely misunderstood by the wife; she views his behavior as a sign
of his callous apathy.
Ultimately, each character is isolated from the other at opposite
ends of the staircase. In order for the marriage to succeed, each character
must travel an equal distance up or down the staircase in order to meet the
other. The husband attempts to empathize with his wife, moving up the staircase
toward her and essentially moving backward in his own journey towards
acceptance of his child’s death. When the wife moves down
the staircase, she assumes the upper hand in the power struggle between the two
by ensuring that her husband cannot move between her and the door and stop her
from leaving. Without the physical capacity to keep her from leaving, the
husband must attempt to convince her to stay through communication - something
that, as the poem demonstrates, has been largely unsuccessful throughout their
marriage.
Which results in the wife’s suicidal feeling
and in the ultimate destruction of their marriage.
Right
from the poem’s opening; the reader can see the conflict between The Reality behind
a Crumbling Marriage Robert Frost’s poem “Home Burial” explores a complicated
male-female dynamic in a crumbling marriage. As a way of reinforcing this issue
in the poem, Robert H.Swennes asserts that the poem shows
“The
decay of the marriage unit in a setting which is harshly realistic and material.”
(Swennes, 366).
“Home Burial” uncovers the conflict under the
surface of a couple’s relationship and how the death of their child serves to
amplify it. Frost demonstrates how convoluted the husband’s feelings are toward
his wife and shows male dominance through symbolism, specific word choice, and
body language used in the dialogue between them. Their deceased child
symbolizes the decay of their relationship. This particular symbolism brings
the destruction full circle in the last moment of the poem. Frost uses
extensively the position of the two speakers on a staircase to symbolize the
emotional and physical distance between the husband, who is never named, and
his wife Amy. Frost ties all these elements in the poem to the theme of male
dominance in the relationship; together these elements show the separation
between the couple Amy and her husband. Frost makes a point early on to call
the wife by her name, Amy, while leaving the husband nameless. In doing so,
Frost emphasizes the idea that the husband’s feelings (or lack of) are not
different from those of any other male in the society of the time; he fits into
the stereotypical norm. Amy, in contrast, feels her grief on a personal level.
This is why the reader is introduced to her by name; it shows her humanity on a
relatable field. The husband asserts his feeling of dominance over his wife by
questioning what it is she sees out of the window at the top of the stairs:
“I will find out now – you
must tell me, dear”. (“Home
Burial”; L- 12).
The fact
that he calls her “dear” is ironic because he has just demanded that she
tell him what she sees that seems to trouble her. He does not make the demand
in a concerned but in a controlling way. Calling her “dear” is another way for
him to prove that she belongs to him and that he can make demands of her because
he “loves” her. Frost suggests stereotypical feminine frailty in his
description of the wife
“[sinking]
upon her skirts” at the inquiry from her husband (“Home Burial”;L- 8).
The
child in this poem symbolizes a once fruitful intimate relationship between the
couple. In the act of digging the grave and burying their dead child, the
husband buried the product of their former loving relationship; he commits to
the earth the proof of the couple’s sexual love (Kearns 194). The wife alludes
to her own desire to commit to the earth their now failing marriage when she
says:
“friends make a pretense of following to the
grave/…I won’t have grief/ So if I can change it” (L-109, 113, 114).
Amy can only escape the turmoil in her life by
following the product of her once loving relationship with her husband to the
grave. Other people, as she says, only say they wish to follow others to the
grave but do not because they still find some joy in life. She
“no
longer conceives herself as a wife, her husband’s lover, or the mother of his
future family” (Swennes 367).
According to W. David Shaw, “if so homely and
event as the death of a son cannot be domesticated, what is to avert the slide
of life itself into some indefinite void?” (Shaw 167). Amy’s life is slipping
away from her, heading towards the grave with her dead child and she intends to
follow, as there appears to be no other alternative in her mind.
The
staircase functions symbolically as a metaphor for the wife’s decent into death
as an escape. The window is at the top of the stairs and through it the wife
glimpses the graveyard (25). This glimpse is possible only at the top of the
stairs, which may symbolize another world beyond the grief of this one. For the
wife, the bottom of the stairs represents her escape. She must descend the
stairs in order to leave her unhappy home and relationship; and to do so she
must get past her husband, who now represents a stranger to her (33-34).
Similarly, her friends “wishing” to go to the grave with loved ones seems
fanciful to her; she intends to do more than just talk about it like them
because she does not wish to live with her grief any longer. Frost implies
suicide as a last resort for Amy and symbolizes it not only through a descent
down the stairs but also through her would-be departure from the confines of
her “grating and sexually brutal, household” (Swennes 369).
The
diction used throughout the poem conveys further the husband’s dominance but
also the wife’s strength in her desire to escape. Amy’s body language and her physical
position in the house throughout the poem symbolize the separation and lack of
affection in their relationship. The wife is standing quite a distance from her
husband on the stairs, representing the distance in their relationship
following the death of their child. The husband comments on this by saying:
“I’m not
so much/Unlike other folks as your
Standing there/Apart would make me out” (“Home Burial”; L- 62-64).
Amy stands apart from him because she feels
that his lack of emotion and inability to grieve and empathize takes him out of
the plane of a being human and into that of a savage. The fact that the wife
“challenges” him to tell her what he thinks she sees out of the upstairs window
shows that she recognizes his attempt at dominance over her and wants to defy
it. Amy shows much strength in the face of her controlling husband, which
itself contradicts female weakness, an ideal presumably held by her husband.
She refuses him any help in figuring out what she sees from the window and
says:
With the least
stiffening of her neck and silence.
She let him look, sure
that he wouldn’t see, (“Home Burial”, L-14,15).
Showing
some passive aggression in her silence and slightly stiffened neck, she does
not feel that her husband has any emotional capacity, demonstrating the
distance in their married life now that the one thing holding their relationship
together is gone. The fact that Amy
“[withdraws] shrinking
from beneath his arm”. (“Home Burial”; L-34)
shows
how he asserts his superiority through an attempt to console her that only
causes her to withdraw within herself more fully. This perpetuates their
misunderstanding of each other because they lack effective communication
evidenced through the dialogue between them.
Their
dialogue shows the basis for their strained relationship. The way he speaks
to Amy
shows an air of condescension and even sounds patronizing. He makes no
attempt
to understand the depth of her sorrow and does not recognize that he could
contribute
to it, especially when he says,
“my words are nearly
always in offense.
I don’t know how to speak of anything
so as to please you” (“Home Burial”;L- 47,48,49).
Although he says this, he makes no attempt to
remedy his lack of understanding and insensitivity. When he says she
To take your mother-loss
of a first child
So inconsolably—in the
face of love.
You’d think his memory
might be satisfied—’(“Home
Burial”;L- 67,68,69)
this would-be loving spouse implies that there
is still love left in the relationship
The wife
feels that this love died with their child and so she disdains her husband’s
lack of understanding for her deep despondence.
Almost
as if he feels he is speaking to another species, the husband reveals a deep-
seated sense of male superiority when he says:
A man must partly give up
being a man
With women-folk. We could
have some arrangement(“Home
Burial”;L- 51,52).
Simply
by accusing the husband of being insensitive to their son’s death, the wife
shows that ‘each type believes the other to be inferior to itself”(Shaw 166).
Frost’s
use of the words “man” and “woman” to differentiate and identify
the two
speakers rather than giving them both names enforces this theme of inferiority.
The
words suggest also the difference between “generic” nameless male “feeling” and
Amy’s deeply personal desolation. When the husband asks,
“Can’t a man speak of his
own child he’s lost”, (“Home
Burial”; L-75)
the word
“man” emphasizes the weight he places on his being the male in the relationship
(36). He implies also feelings of possession regarding their deceased child
when he speaks of the child “he’s lost” without reference to the fact that Amy
has lost a child too. The wife, being the maternal figure, feels she is
entitled to grieve because she has a deeper connection with the child that she
birthed. She asserts this when she says in response to his question,
“I don’t know rightly
whether any man can” (“Home Burial”; L- 39).
. The
word “mounting” in contrast to “cowered” implies the contrast between what
should be pleasurable between a couple and what is actually controlling and
frightening. It is inferred that his governance over her life extends into
areas that should afford pleasure as well, leading into the further conflict of
the death of their child as a symbol of their lost intimacy and now doomed
marriage. In the final scene between these former lovers, the husband shouts at
his wife as she opens wider the door to their home, symbolically heading closer
to the conclusion of her life and permanently ending her doomed marriage. He
calls after her,
‘If—you—do!’ She was
opening the door wider.
‘Where do you mean to
go? First tell me that.
I’ll follow and bring you
back by force. I will!—’(“Home Burial”L-119-121)
The husband does not understand that by
following his wife where she intends to go, not only will
he be unable to bring her back, but he will also be unable to return himself.
Unbeknownst to this hard, unfeeling man, by attempting to control the last
effort from Amy, he is committing himself to her chosen fate. The husband has
condemned their love to death, unwittingly. The closing act of their life as a
couple becomes the commission of their marriage to the earth, just as they have
done with their dead son. No rebirth comes from these “plantings” in the dirt,
only ultimate destruction of their already crumbling marriage, the ultimate
“home” burial.
"Birches" is another extremely symbolic poem. In the
poem Birches by Robert Frost, Frost portrays the images of a child growing to
adulthood through the symbolism of aging birch trees. Through these images
readers are able to see the reality of the real world compared to their
carefree childhood. The image of life through tribulation is the main focal
point of the poem and the second point of the poem is if one could revert back
to the simpler times of childhood. The language of the poem is entirely
arranged through images, although it contains some diction it lacks sound
devices, metaphors, and similes compared to other published works by Frost. The
first half of the poems’ images are of life, coming of age, and death.
The first three lines in the poem represent the image of childhood and adulthood.
The first three lines in the poem represent the image of childhood and adulthood.
“When I
see birches bend to left and right
Across
the lines of straighter darker trees,
I like
to think some boy’s been swinging them.”( "Birches";L,1-3)
Childhood
is represented when the branches swing Frost thinks there is a boy swinging on
them. Adulthood is represented by straighter darker trees because darker is a
reference to older trees just by the nature of the color as compared to a birch
tree which is white or light in color. “But swinging doesn't bend them down to
stay. Ice storms do. Often you must have seen them Loaded with ice a sunny
winter morning. In this poem the poet relates a common incident when, he, as a
boy was jumping from one branch to another of birches, but as the poem
progresses, the poet quietly introduces a deep philosophy that love, of earth
is essential for climbing heavenward. All this is done so effortlessly that the
ordinary reader fails to take notice of it on a
casual reading, but when we turn
to the poem repeatedly, we are amazed to find a wealth of thought the following
lines contain :
I'd like
to get away from earth awhile
And then come back to it and begin over.
May no fate willfully misunderstand me
And half grant what I wish and snatch me away
Not to return. Earth's the right place for love:
I don't know where it's likely to go better.
I'd like to go by climbing a birch tree,
And climb black branches up a snow-white trunk
Toward heaven, till the tree could bear no more,
But dipped its top and set me down again.
That would be good both going and coming back.
One could do worse than be a swinger of birches.( "Birches";L,55-60)
And then come back to it and begin over.
May no fate willfully misunderstand me
And half grant what I wish and snatch me away
Not to return. Earth's the right place for love:
I don't know where it's likely to go better.
I'd like to go by climbing a birch tree,
And climb black branches up a snow-white trunk
Toward heaven, till the tree could bear no more,
But dipped its top and set me down again.
That would be good both going and coming back.
One could do worse than be a swinger of birches.( "Birches";L,55-60)
An
important criterion of great poetry is that it does not yield its meaning at
the first reading We have to go back to it again and again to appreciate it
properly, and every time we take it up, even after years of interval, it looks
fresh and an unthought-of facet of it ,is presented to our understanding.
Another very significant poem from the point of view of inherent
symbolism is "An Old Man's Winter
Night." The poem tells us of an old man sitting alone in his farmhouse
on an intense winter night. We find him standing alone in a "creaking
room", unable to see anything out of the windows, unable to remember the
reason of his coming here. The imagery
of night in the poem is very significant:
A light
he was to no one but himself
Where
now he sat, concerned with he knew not what,
A quiet light, and then
not even that.(
"An Old Man's Winter Night."L-15,16,17)
The inner light goes out as he falls asleep, and all that remains
is the concealed light which is coming from the stove and the pale moonlight
outside. The faint light emphasizes the fact that the light of this old man is
also out and he himself does not know the reason of his living. His life is a
living death almost. Thus the poem is
not only a poem of old age, it is also a poem about death. Since old age, night and winter are mixed by
the poet into one, we see death as a disappearance of order and meaning. Order and meaning in external world depend
upon the organizing power of the mind.
On this symbolic level too we can appreciate this poem. However, the whole meaning of the poem is more
complex. Frost emphasizes the fact that
there are two kinds of order, human and natural. When human order is destroyed.-natural order
still continues. So, when the old man
is not able to keep his house, farm and countryside, these are kept by the
moon. The house and the farm, when
combined with the countryside, take on a very wide significance. The farmstead, like the house in which T. S.
Eliot pictures "Gerontian" suggests, says Lyncn,
"human institutions, society
as a whole, and even an entire culture ; and the countryside of the old man,
the nation, and beyond this, the world."
The poem “Mowing” is one of the most anthologized poems of Robert
Frost. It is also the symbolical poem of Robert Frost. It is a significant
lyric which was first published in A boy’s Will. It is subtle poem in which the
poet describes one of the basic and most important activities in the field of
agriculture.
Ostensibly, the speaker muses about the sound a scythe makes
mowing hay in a field by a forest, and what this sound might signify. He
rejects the idea that it speaks of something dreamlike or supernatural,
concluding that reality of the work itself is rewarding enough, and the speaker
need not call on fanciful invention.
As the narrator works in the field on a hot day, he notices that
his scythe seems to be whispering as it works. The narrator is unable to hear
what the scythe is saying, and he admits the possibility that the whispering
sound is simply his imagination or even the result of heatstroke. He eventually
concludes that the scythe is expressing its own beliefs about the world.
Instead of dreaming about inactivity or reward for its labor as a person would,
the scythe takes its sole pleasure from its hard work. It receives satisfaction
from “the fact” of its earnest labor in the field, not from transient dreams or
irrational hopes. As the poem ends, the narrator ceases his own unimportant
musings and follows the scythe’s example: seizing on the pleasure of hard work
and making hay.
This poem is one of the first
in which Frost utilizes his “sound of sense” technique. Within this technique,
the poet employs specific sounds and syllables in order to construct an aural
feeling of the subject and narrative intention. In this case, both the repeated
use of the term “whisper” and the swaying motion of the meter in certain lines
“Something perhaps, about the
lack of sound”(“Mowing”
L-5)
It is provide a visceral sense
of the scythe moving back and forth as it cuts the hay in the field. The fact that Frost uses the word “whisper” is significant because it personifies the scythe, transforming it into a companion and working colleague for the narrator rather than an inanimate farming tool. With that in mind, the scythe and its philosophical view on work could actually be seen as a reflection of the narrator’s own beliefs, or rather a belief that the farmer hopes to have as he continues to work on his farm. The circular nature of the poem supports this claim: by the end of the poem, the narrator has stopped attempting to analyze the scythe’s whispering within his imagination and has resorted to simple, honest work.
This mentality can be expanded as Frost’s justification of his own poetic sensibility. Frost was well known (and often criticized) for writing poetry about everyday life on the farms of New England - a topic that did not always seem appropriate for the high art of poetry. Yet, as Frost points out in “Mowing,” truth and fact are far more significant than imaginative fancies of gold and elves. In other words, his emphasis on reality — the lives and struggles of real people — makes his poetry sweeter and more effective than any traditional sonnet that narrates fairytale lands.
The first thing that struck me on reading it, and which would
probably occur to even the most blunt-brained reader, was the prevalence of
lush, sibilant whispering s-sounds thought the piece which emulate the sound of
the scythe scarping off the grass.
Through the use of the first person, the inverted syntax of the
opening line which creates suspense and curiosity, and lines like L4&5,
Frost gives this piece a conversational tone, as if one were sitting in a room
with him while he tells a story.
Much of it is also cast in the negative: "knew not well", "there was never a sound" but that of the scythe, "it was no dream of ...idle hours", "[it was no dream of] ... easy gold". These negative statements, like the opening line, defer the revelation of what the scythe whispers to the end of the poem, impelling the reader to read on to discover the scythe's secret.
Much of it is also cast in the negative: "knew not well", "there was never a sound" but that of the scythe, "it was no dream of ...idle hours", "[it was no dream of] ... easy gold". These negative statements, like the opening line, defer the revelation of what the scythe whispers to the end of the poem, impelling the reader to read on to discover the scythe's secret.
The scythe as symbol, It
is really used symbolically. The Poet said that..
There was never a sound beside the wood but one,
And that was my long scythe whispering to the ground.(“Mowing”; L-1, 2)
And that was my long scythe whispering to the ground.(“Mowing”; L-1, 2)
Stripped of everything, this poem is a
monologue about a scythe. A worker is mowing, but Frost doesn't write about the
worker or the field - only the sound of the scythe. And that sound is quiet. It
is a whisper. How very different from the swinging arc of the scythe which cuts
mercilessly: scything is in truth fearful and forceful and violent. It destroys
and cuts down life. Is not death portrayed as a hooded skeleton carrying a
scythe? The scythe has long been used as a symbol for time which harvests us
all in death.
"Anything more than the truth would have seemed too weak..." And there lies our key to unlocking this poem. Our normal way of speaking would have been to say "Anything less than the truth." But Frost wants nothing more than the truth. To convey more than the truth would be to dream. Truth is less than dream. And now we see the import of those negatives. Truth is a cutting away, a narrowing down, a removing of what is not relevant. Like scything, really.
Frost has lovingly and laboriously laid the lines of the poem like rows of swale and to understand them you have to lean in close to hear the whisper of the scythe. But that meaning is elusive. It isn't handed to you. The meaning of the poem is made, like hay, through labor and is always, by definition, incomplete.
"Anything more than the truth would have seemed too weak..." And there lies our key to unlocking this poem. Our normal way of speaking would have been to say "Anything less than the truth." But Frost wants nothing more than the truth. To convey more than the truth would be to dream. Truth is less than dream. And now we see the import of those negatives. Truth is a cutting away, a narrowing down, a removing of what is not relevant. Like scything, really.
Frost has lovingly and laboriously laid the lines of the poem like rows of swale and to understand them you have to lean in close to hear the whisper of the scythe. But that meaning is elusive. It isn't handed to you. The meaning of the poem is made, like hay, through labor and is always, by definition, incomplete.
Frosts
use of "orchises" and the scythe being described as "long and
hard" is quite significant. Orchises is derived from the Greek word,
Orchis, meaning "testicles" and the sycthe is obviously a phallic
symbol. This fits in well, for those familiar with Frosts life, as he was a
latent homosexual.
The poem
"After Apple Picking" can also be appreciated on the symbolic level.
Robert Frost “After Apple Picking” This extract comes from North of Boston, a
selection of poems from the eminent American poet Robert Frost. Like most of
the other poems in the book, Frost's After Apple Picking reads like a short
drama. Like The Mending Wall or the Woodpile, this poem is narrated from a
first-person point of view, where the poet refers to himself as "I"
and is a principal actor in the poem- continuing to describe his setting,
emotions and thoughts throughout. Frost, who is renowned for his figurative use
of language, is sometimes counted amongst the ranks of the transcendentalist
poets. Transcendentalism often amounted to drawing upon an individual sense of
consciousness whilst eschewing the intellectualism of the day. A greater
spiritual appreciation was appraised for the setting that influenced the
transcendentalist and, thus, North of Boston is imbued with a dreamy quality
whilst still retaining a vivid appreciation of nature. It is also interesting
to note that some literary critics have called the transcendentalism an
"American Romanticism" movement- and indeed, many of Frost's poems
have a strong inclination toward nature combined with aesthetic appreciation
for emotion and feeling. After Apple Picking is, in itself, a marvelous
representation of Frost's philosophy and writing style- though it is somewhat
unfortunate that no definite interpretations of the poem can be agreed upon.
The poem
describes the experiences of an apple-picker who has been working throughout
the day with his long two-pointed ladder which is stitl looking up towards the
sky. In the poem "After Apple Picking", Robert Frost uses many
symbols to enhance the meaning of the poem. The apple in the poem could be
symbolic of be said to be the forbidden fruit from the Garden of Eden. The
Garden of Eden was basically the beginning of everything earthly and heavenly,
therefore repelling death. For you to understand the poem, you have to realize
that for something to be dead, it must have been alive before. This may not be
the central theme of the poem but Frost's symbolic use of the apple makes this
concept as important. This poem is about life but its focuses are what are in
between, the missed life experiences and the regret that the speaker is left
with.
He can still see the unpicked apples hanging
on the branches. But he is obviously tired and is in no mood to go on. The
smell of the apples and his own tiredness conspire to make him drowsy and he
lies down to sleep. This is the concrete experience very realistically
presented by the poet. But the poem invites a symbolic interpretation as well.
The drowsiness which the apple-picker feels after the day's labor is associated
with the cycle of seasons Its special character is emphasized by a bit of magic:
Essence
of winter sleep is on the night.
The scent of apples. I am drowsing off
I cannot rub the strangeness from my sight
I got from looking through a pane of glass
I
skimmed this morning from the drinking trough
And held
against the world of heavy grass,
It melted, and I let it fall and break.(“After Apple Picking”; L,
7-12)
The
speaker then speculates about the forms which his dreaming will take. He feels that the apples will still
come in his dream for his instep
arch still feels the pressure of the ladder rung, and his cars are still full of the rumble of
apples rolling into the cellar cabin. But he returns to the subject of his
drowsiness and the phrase 'whatever sleep it is' renews his suggestion that
his sleepiness may not be ordinary human sleepiness:
Were he not gone,
The
woodchuck could say whether it's like his
Long
sleep, as I describe its coming on,
Or
just some human sleep. .(“After Apple Picking”; L, 39-42)
The end
of the labor sends the poet a sense of fulfillment. In the words of Cleanth
Brooks, "The poem even suggests that sleep is like the sleep of death. We
are not to feel that the speaker is essentially conscious of this. But perhaps
we are to feel that were the analogy to present itself to him, he would accept
it. In the context defined in the poem, death might be considered as something
eminently natural as a sense of fulfillment mixed with a great deal of honest
weariness and a sense of something well done—though with too much drowsiness,
for one to bother that every one of the apples had not been picked."
Robert Frost used
the action of picking apples in After
Apple-Picking to signify any task and drowsiness to symbolize the changing of the seasons.
In custom research papers on After Apple-Picking, it is shown that both
concepts take on a boarder meaning in After Apple-Picking, as does the act of
sleep itself. The research papers show at the end of After Apple-Picking the
worker is filled with a sense of fulfillment, just as one would be at the end
of a life well lived. In reading After Apple-Picking, the reader is free to apply
After Apple-Picking strictly to a New England task of picking and storing the
apples before the changing of the seasons or to apply the boarder meaning as
related to life in general.
No comments